Shopify Plus vs Magento (Adobe Commerce) for B2B eCommerce

For B2B manufacturers and distributors evaluating platforms in 2025–2026, Shopify Plus has overtaken Magento as the default choice. Magento's open-source flexibility comes with hosting complexity, security patching, and upgrade debt. Shopify Plus delivers native B2B features — company accounts, catalogs, volume pricing — on a fully managed SaaS platform with 99.99% uptime.

We've migrated clients from Magento to Shopify Plus and built B2B storefronts on both platforms. Here's an honest comparison.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Feature Shopify Plus Magento / Adobe Commerce
Hosting Fully managed SaaS — 99.99% uptime, automatic scaling, global CDN Self-hosted or Adobe Commerce Cloud — you manage infrastructure, scaling, and uptime
B2B native features Yes — company accounts, catalogs, price lists, volume pricing, net terms Requires Adobe B2B module (paid) or third-party extensions
Total cost of ownership Lower — $2,300–$2,500/month platform fee, no hosting or patching costs Higher — hosting, security patches, version upgrades, DevOps team
Time to launch 8–16 weeks typical for mid-market B2B 6–12 months typical, longer for complex customizations
ERP integration Via Patchworks iPaaS, native apps, or custom middleware Custom development required — no standard middleware layer
Checkout extensibility Shopify Functions (WASM, sandboxed) — safe, versioned, platform-managed Full codebase access — unlimited flexibility, unlimited maintenance burden
PIM integration Akeneo, Salsify, Jasper via connectors or middleware Akeneo, Salsify via custom integration development
Security PCI DSS Level 1 compliant, managed by Shopify — zero patches for you You are responsible for security patches, PCI compliance, and pen testing
Upgrades Automatic — every merchant runs the latest version Manual — major version upgrades cost $50K–$150K+ and take months

When Magento Still Makes Sense

We're not ideologues. Magento remains a viable platform in specific scenarios:

  • Deep checkout customization — If your B2B checkout requires logic that can't be expressed through Shopify Functions (rare, but possible for highly regulated industries).
  • Existing Magento investment — If you've spent $500K+ on custom Magento modules that work well and your team maintains them effectively.
  • Adobe ecosystem — If you're already on Adobe Experience Cloud (AEM, Target, Analytics) and want tight native integration.
  • Self-hosted requirements — If regulations require you to host customer data on your own infrastructure (some government or defense contracts).

For most mid-market B2B operations — manufacturers, distributors, and wholesalers doing $10M–$500M — these scenarios don't apply. The cost and complexity of Magento outweigh the flexibility.

When to Choose Shopify Plus

  • Speed matters — You need to launch a B2B storefront in 8–16 weeks, not 6–12 months.
  • Lower TCO — You want to eliminate hosting, patching, and upgrade costs. Your IT budget goes to features, not infrastructure.
  • Native B2B features — Company accounts, catalogs, volume pricing, and net terms are built in. No third-party modules to maintain.
  • Managed infrastructure — 99.99% uptime SLA, automatic scaling for traffic spikes, PCI compliance handled for you.
  • ERP integration via middleware — Patchworks iPaaS or custom middleware connects Shopify Plus to your ERP without custom server-side code.
  • Hybrid B2B + B2C — Serve wholesale and retail from one storefront, one inventory, one admin panel.
  • Future-proof — Shopify invests $1B+/year in platform development. Every merchant runs the latest version automatically.

What a Magento → Shopify Plus Migration Looks Like

Phase 1: Discovery and audit (2–3 weeks)

We audit your current Magento setup — custom modules, integrations, data model, URL structure, SEO performance — and document what needs to migrate, what can be replaced with native Shopify Plus features, and what requires custom development.

Phase 2: Build and migrate (6–10 weeks)

We build your Shopify Plus storefront, set up B2B features (company accounts, catalogs, pricing), reconnect your ERP, migrate customer data and order history, and implement 301 redirects for every indexed URL.

Phase 3: Launch and optimize (2–4 weeks)

UAT with your team, buyer onboarding, SEO monitoring, and post-launch performance tuning. We monitor search rankings, fix crawl issues, and ensure your B2B buyers adopt the new platform.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Shopify Plus cheaper than Magento for B2B?
In total cost of ownership, yes. Shopify Plus costs $2,300–$2,500/month for the platform, with no hosting, security patching, or infrastructure costs. Magento/Adobe Commerce requires hosting ($500–$5,000/month), a dedicated DevOps team or managed hosting provider, regular security patches, and version upgrades that can cost $50K–$150K+ each. Over 3 years, most mid-market B2B operations spend 40–60% less on Shopify Plus than on Magento.
Can I migrate from Magento to Shopify Plus without losing SEO?
Yes. We handle Magento-to-Shopify Plus migrations with full URL redirect mapping, metadata preservation, structured data migration, and Search Console monitoring. The key is a comprehensive redirect map (301s for every indexed URL), canonical URL setup, and hreflang tags for multilingual sites. Most clients see traffic recovery within 4–8 weeks post-migration.
Does Shopify Plus support the same B2B features as Magento?
Shopify Plus now includes native B2B features that match or exceed Magento's B2B module: company accounts with multiple buyers and locations, customer-specific catalogs and pricing, volume pricing and quantity rules, net payment terms, draft orders for quote workflows, and B2B checkout customization via Shopify Functions. Where Magento requires third-party extensions, Shopify Plus delivers these natively.
When should I stay on Magento instead of migrating to Shopify Plus?
Magento may still be the better choice if you have deeply custom checkout logic that can't be replicated with Shopify Functions, significant investment in custom Magento modules that would be expensive to rebuild, regulatory requirements that mandate self-hosted infrastructure, or you're already on Adobe Commerce Cloud with a committed contract. For most mid-market B2B operations, though, Shopify Plus delivers faster time to value at lower cost.

Planning a migration?

We've migrated B2B operations from Magento, BigCommerce, and legacy platforms to Shopify Plus. Let's discuss your situation.

Talk to us about your migration →